Signal’s Intriguing Ties and the Implications for Users
In the realm of digital communications, the encrypted messaging service Signal stands out as the go-to platform for individuals seeking privacy, including political dissidents worldwide. With an impressive user base exceeding 100 million downloads, Signal has earned endorsements from notable figures such as Edward Snowden and Elon Musk, establishing an image of a safe haven for secure conversations beyond the reach of governmental oversight or retaliation.
However, the backstory of Signal presents a tapestry of connections that may seem at odds with its privacy-focused image. The app’s developmental roots can be traced to a million grant from the Open Technology Fund (OTF), a government-sponsored entity that evolved from Radio Free Asia, a Cold War-era broadcaster. The OTF’s mission to fund “encrypted mobile communication tools” for “Internet freedom defenders globally” has been an integral part of Signal’s inception.
Despite the ostensibly benign intentions, some insiders suggest that the OTF’s ties to U.S. intelligence may be more intricate than publicly acknowledged. A source with extensive experience with the OTF, who preferred to remain anonymous, expressed concerns about the project being a veneer for a State Department initiative. The purpose, as described by the insider, was to leverage open-source Internet projects as instruments for advancing U.S. foreign policy goals, particularly by empowering activists and political factions disfavored by the U.S.
Adding another layer to this complex narrative is Katherine Maher, the current chairman of the Signal Foundation’s board. Maher’s professional journey includes a chapter as a U.S.-supported agent of change during the Arab Spring, where she spearheaded digital communication efforts in the Middle East and North Africa for the National Democratic Institute. Her role involved nurturing relationships with dissidents and employing American technology to promote U.S.-backed movements abroad.
Maher’s trajectory continued as she assumed the role of CEO at the Wikimedia Foundation and later as CEO of National Public Radio. Her tenure at Wikipedia was marked by a strong stance against “disinformation,” admitting to coordinating censorship efforts in discussion with government entities. She also publicly supported the deplatforming of individuals labeled as “fascists,” and viewed the First Amendment as an obstacle to eradicating “bad information.”
The narrative takes another turn with Meredith Whittaker’s presidency over the Signal Foundation in 2022, who then brought Maher on board. Both share a history with the OTF and a dedication to organizations such as Access Now, which champions digital rights. Whittaker is no stranger to activism herself, having played a significant role in Google’s internal movements for workplace reform.
These revelations have stirred unease among American users, including conservative groups, who rely on Signal for protected communications. National security expert J. Michael Waller voices his concern over Maher’s involvement, suggesting that her history and potential intelligence ties may cast a shadow over Signal’s reputation for trustworthiness. This sentiment is echoed by David Heinemeier Hansson, who acknowledges the increased difficulty in maintaining confidence in the Signal Foundation’s direction.
The question of Internet freedom and its stewardship under Maher’s ideology is one that raises flags for proponents of a genuinely open web. Maher has previously indicated a departure from the tenets of an unrestricted Internet, criticizing its “white male Westernized construct” and advocating for a more curated approach to online discourse, one that deftly balances censorship and the promotion of dissent based on strategic objectives.
As we navigate this evolving landscape of political technology, Maher’s philosophy suggests that for her, “Internet freedom” is a means to an end, and “fighting disinformation” involves curbing speech—a stance that could have profound implications for digital communication on a global scale.
Photo by Jaap Arriens/NurPhoto via Getty Images
