Copycat is a game where players assume the role of an elderly lady named Olive who adopts a cat from a shelter. The narrative reveals Olive's past experiences with pet adoption and her emotional connection to the animals. After adopting a rebellious ginger cat named Dawn, players navigate the complexities of their relationship, including Olive's history with a previous cat that disappeared. The game explores themes of choice and agency, as well as the emotional stakes involved when Olive faces an accident that leads to her hospitalization. This results in Dawn being abandoned, highlighting the cycle of neglect that shelter animals endure. Dawn's brief experience of freedom on the streets contrasts with the challenges she faces, including the emotional impact of being replaced by another cat. The game oscillates between lighthearted moments and profound sorrow, ultimately emphasizing the importance of compassion for animals in need.