Microsoft asking us to buy new Windows 11 PCs is wasteful

Microsoft’s push for users to transition to Windows 11 has met with a notable resistance from the Windows 10 community. Many users are hesitant to upgrade, largely due to the stringent hardware requirements imposed by the new operating system. The initial uproar began when Microsoft released an upgrade tool that flagged many capable PCs as incompatible, primarily due to their lack of support for TPM 2.0, a requirement that cannot be retrofitted onto existing hardware without a complete replacement.

Despite the initial concerns, recent updates to Windows 11, particularly the 24H2 version, have demonstrated that older hardware can indeed run the operating system effectively. Users who took the plunge found that their older machines performed better than expected, countering the narrative that only new hardware could handle Windows 11. This improvement in performance across various devices may encourage more users to finally embrace the update.

Some older hardware can still run Windows 11 perfectly well

As it turns out, the real issue isn’t the lack of processing power in older machines, but rather the TPM 2.0 requirement that continues to frustrate users. The reality is that many older CPUs possess the capability to run Windows 11 smoothly, yet they are sidelined due to this specific limitation.

Windows 11’s requirements sends a signal that old CPUs are “useless”

To run Windows 11 without circumventing the requirements, users must have a CPU that supports TPM 2.0. This requirement has inadvertently labeled older CPUs as obsolete, despite their potential to perform adequately. The situation raises concerns about e-waste, as users are encouraged to discard functional hardware simply because it does not meet a specific criterion.

With the growing issue of electronic waste, Microsoft’s insistence on hardware upgrades appears counterproductive. The company’s approach may exacerbate the problem, as many users are likely to dispose of perfectly capable machines rather than invest in costly upgrades.

In the end, it may just be a big push for Copilot+ sales

Underlying this hardware push is a strategic motive: Microsoft aims to drive sales of its new Copilot+ devices, which leverage AI to enhance user productivity. The ideal scenario for Microsoft is for users to abandon their Windows 10 systems, acquire a Copilot+ device, and subscribe to additional features for a monthly fee. However, the current offerings may not justify the investment, leaving users at a crossroads between upgrading and maintaining their existing systems.

Ultimately, for those whose PCs continue to function well, there are numerous alternatives to consider, including non-Windows operating systems. As Windows 10 approaches its end-of-life, users will need to weigh their options carefully, balancing the desire for new features against the practicality of their current hardware.

Winsage