For many, the desktop PC is more than just a machine; it embodies a collection of memories and experiences that shape our technological journey. Each operating system (OS) we encounter leaves an indelible mark, often tied to significant moments in our lives. Windows XP, for instance, is not merely remembered for its functionality or aesthetics but for the nostalgia of school days spent playing flash games, sharing USB sticks with friends, and exploring the burgeoning internet.
Reflecting on my own history, I recall the quirks of Windows 98—the crashes, the peculiar wallpapers, and the clunky interface. Friends with Windows 2000 shared similar frustrations, as their systems struggled under the weight of the OS. The introduction of Windows XP felt like a revelation, ushering in a golden era of gaming and online communities, while Vista marked my teenage years with its own set of challenges. As I transitioned into my professional career in tech journalism, Windows 10 emerged, hailed by many as one of Microsoft’s finest offerings, second only to XP.
(Image credit: TechRadar)
Ch-ch-ch-ch-changes
With Windows 11, Microsoft has introduced a series of changes that have sparked both intrigue and controversy. The most notable alteration is the taskbar’s new “Apple-esque” centered design, which has left some long-time users feeling unsettled. However, unlike many other operating systems, Windows 11 allows for customization. Users can realign the taskbar, remove unnecessary features, and even eliminate the presence of Microsoft’s Copilot AI if they so choose.
The Start Menu, initially cluttered with ads and unused applications, can also be tailored to individual preferences, transforming it into a more efficient tool. In essence, Windows 11 serves as a refined iteration of Windows 10, much like how 8.1 improved upon its predecessor. While some features, such as DirectStorage, are exclusive to Windows 11, the overall experience feels smoother and more user-friendly, especially on modern hardware. The expanded settings menus offer greater accessibility, enhancing the user experience significantly.
The challenges faced by Windows 11
Yet, Windows 11 is not without its flaws. The presence of ads for services like OneDrive and Office365, despite the hefty price tag of around 9 for a license, raises concerns about user experience. Many users feel that after investing in the OS, they shouldn’t be inundated with promotional notifications.
Moreover, the requirement for TPM 2.0 for installation has rendered many older systems obsolete, raising questions about sustainability and economic impact. As Windows 10 approaches its end-of-life, users with functioning systems now face potential vulnerabilities unless they upgrade. This situation is particularly concerning for government agencies and organizations with limited resources, as they may struggle to meet Microsoft’s new security standards.
Kiss, marry, push off a cliff
When examining the broader landscape of operating systems, Windows 11 stands out amidst a sea of alternatives. ChromeOS, while user-friendly, is often limited to basic tasks. macOS, known for its robust design, can feel restrictive, particularly for gaming. Linux offers flexibility but can be daunting for newcomers. In comparison, Windows 11 remains my preferred choice, despite its challenges, with one notable exception: Windows on Arm, which I have yet to embrace fully.
