Warner Bros. finds itself navigating choppy waters once again, as the initial wave of reviews for A Minecraft Movie has surfaced on Rotten Tomatoes, revealing a decidedly “rotten” reception. This adaptation of the beloved video game features Jack Black in the role of Steve, who embarks on a quest alongside a group of four misfits. The ensemble cast includes Jason Momoa as “The Garbage Man,” Emma Myers as Natalie, Danielle Brooks as Dawn, and Sebastian Hansen as Henry, with Jennifer Coolidge portraying Vice Principal Marlene.
Set in a world defined by creativity and imagination, the characters must learn to survive and fend off threats from Piglins, Zombies, and other perils to find their way home. With Steve’s expertise in crafting, they aim to rediscover their creativity—an essential element for thriving both in Minecraft and the real world.
In an intriguing addition, an extended preview of James Gunn’s upcoming Superman film will accompany screenings of A Minecraft Movie.
What is the Minecraft movie Rotten Tomatoes score?
As of now, the film holds a 53% score based on the first 45 reviews. The fan score will be unveiled following the film’s release, which kicks off with Thursday previews and officially on Friday.
What do the reviews say?
The good:
Jack Black & Jason Momoa’s Chemistry
Critics have noted the dynamic chemistry between Jack Black and Jason Momoa as a standout feature. Their lively and silly interactions inject a sense of fun into the film, contributing to its quirky charm.
“The comedic duo we didn’t know we needed.” – Peter Gray, The AU Review
“Surprisingly fun and positive… also accessible for non-fans.” – Grace Randolph
Faithful to Minecraft’s Spirit
Some reviewers appreciated the film’s ability to capture the essence of the game, embracing its sandbox nature and boundless creativity.
“Captures the ‘anything can happen’ spirit.” – Travis Hopson, Punch Drunk Critics
“A breath of fresh air after so many family films that seem preordained by lore.” – Jordan Hoffman, Entertainment Weekly
Fun for Kids and Families
The film appears to resonate well with younger audiences, with some critics describing it as “uproariously good fun.”
“Kids, whether they’re fans of the game or not, will likely enjoy it.” – Meredith G. White, Arizona Republic
Director Jared Hess’ Style
Director Jared Hess has garnered praise for his playful and absurdist approach, reminiscent of his work in Napoleon Dynamite.
“Fully and hilariously a Jared Hess movie.” – Sean P. Means, The Movie Cricket
“More identity here than most factory-line adaptations.” – Brandon Yu, NYT
The bad:
Lack of Depth or Coherence
Conversely, many critics have pointed out that the film suffers from a lack of depth and coherence, often relying on brand recognition rather than robust storytelling.
“Pointless… dearth of consequence.” – Trace Sauveur, AwardsWatch
“Clunky mess lacking in genuine imagination.” – Soren Andersen, Seattle Times
Unfunny & Poor CGI
A number of reviewers have labeled it as one of the less successful video game adaptations, criticizing its humor and visual effects.
“Painfully unfunny… ugly to look at.” – Ryan Guar, Discussing Film
Corporate, Soulless Feel
A recurring theme in the critiques is the perception of the film as a corporate endeavor, lacking genuine affection for the source material.
“Cinema in service of nothing more than IP exploitation.” – Nick Schager, Daily Beast
“Saw infinite possibilities… and chose the one made a thousand times before.” – Jacob Oller, AV Club
Missed Opportunity for Older Fans
While the film may entertain children, adults seeking nostalgia or deeper narratives may find themselves disenchanted.
“Not enough storytelling or humor to get us invested.” – Meredith G. White, Arizona Republic
“Digging straight down: a terrible idea.” – Jonathan Sim, ComingSoon
