Despite my loyalty to Samsung as my primary smartphone, I find myself appreciating the Pixel 8 as a capable companion. While it may not boast the latest features of the Pixel 10 series, the experience of using Android 16 has been delightful. The software is responsive and user-friendly, yet I often find myself yearning for the robust features that the Galaxy S24 FE offers, particularly in terms of software capabilities. Among the features I miss most are Modes, Routines, and Good Lock, but the stock file manager presents the most significant challenge should I decide to make the Pixel my main device. While Files by Google is functional, it simply cannot compete with the superior capabilities of Samsung My Files.
Which is the better file manager?
In a recent poll, Samsung My Files emerged as the clear favorite, garnering 56% of the votes, while Files by Google received only 18%. A notable 26% of respondents preferred other file management solutions, indicating a diverse range of user preferences.
Own a NAS? My Files knows what you need
Samsung’s My Files may not have the most imaginative name, but it is a surprisingly powerful tool for file management. For those who regularly access a NAS or file server, My Files stands out as the superior choice. Its Network Storage Manager extension allows seamless connections to FTP servers and other network storage via SMB. The built-in wizard simplifies the process of adding these locations, scanning the network for available shares. Within moments, I was able to browse my network shares without any lag, and the experience of scrubbing through videos was impressively smooth.
In contrast, Files by Google lacks the capability to connect to network storage, limiting its functionality to cloud storage access, primarily Google Drive. My Files also supports OneDrive, making it a more versatile option for Windows users.
Smarter search and recall
When it comes to searching for files, My Files outperforms its Google counterpart in a surprising twist. The search functionality allows users to delve into the contents of documents, not just their titles. This feature is invaluable for locating specific information within text-heavy files. For instance, I was able to find an invoice by searching for the term “tax,” a task that proved fruitless with Files by Google.
Additionally, My Files enhances the browsing experience with its breadcrumb menu, enabling users to navigate back through directories effortlessly. This feature is absent in Files by Google, which requires multiple taps to retrace steps.
Google Files still wins in some areas
While Samsung’s My Files excels in many respects, it is not without its shortcomings. Google Files offers distinct advantages, such as the Safe Folder feature, which allows users to secure sensitive content with a PIN or pattern. This level of privacy is not matched by My Files.
Moreover, Google Files provides quick access to features like Quick Share and Scan, which are conveniently located at the bottom of the app. This accessibility is particularly beneficial for users who frequently share files across devices. Additionally, Files by Google boasts smarter storage management tools, especially for those utilizing Google Photos, with an automatic image cleaner that helps free up space.
Visually, Files by Google presents a more appealing interface, thanks to its Material 3 design, which offers a clean and engaging user experience.
The kicker? I’d still choose a third-party file manager over both
Despite my appreciation for the aesthetics of Files by Google, I must acknowledge that Samsung My Files is the more capable stock file manager. It provides direct access to files beyond the smartphone, superior search capabilities, and a proficient built-in video player. However, both stock options ultimately fall short of the advanced features offered by third-party file management apps.
For most users, Samsung My Files and Files by Google deliver essential file management tools with some added functionality. Yet, for those seeking greater control and versatility, a third-party solution is advisable. If I were limited to a stock file manager on my Pixel, I would gladly choose Samsung My Files for its comprehensive features. Perhaps Google could take a cue from Samsung’s design and functionality to enhance its own offerings.
