Windows 11’s Start menu has become a focal point of discussion among users, eliciting a spectrum of reactions as the redesigned interface gradually rolls out. While some users express dissatisfaction with the changes, others find merit in the new design. Interestingly, a segment of the community is frustrated not by the design itself, but by the fact that they have yet to receive the update.
In a recent Reddit thread highlighted by Windows Central, the conversation surrounding the Start menu has taken a polarized turn. One user remarked, “So big, it’s basically a Start screen again,” drawing a comparison to the full-screen Start menu of Windows 8, which was met with considerable backlash at the time. This sentiment resonates with others who feel that the new Start menu resembles a second desktop, overwhelming users with its size.
The perception of the Start menu’s dimensions is not uniform; it varies based on screen size, resolution, and interface scaling. Users with larger screens may find themselves facing the more expansive 8-column layout, which has garnered the most complaints. In contrast, those experiencing the smaller 6-column version seem to be more content. For those struggling with the larger interface, there are workarounds available, including hacks to enable the smaller layout or the use of third-party customization applications.
Another prevalent concern among users is the lack of customization options within the Start menu. Since the revamped UI was first introduced nearly a year ago, feedback has been mixed regarding the automated categorization of apps. While the intention behind this feature is to create a more organized and compact view, many users have found the execution lacking. Particularly, applications related to PC gaming often find themselves miscategorized or lumped into an ambiguous ‘Other’ category, leading to frustration among users who wish to have more control over their app organization.
Layout options
Despite the criticisms, there is a silver lining in the customization aspect: the removal of the section displaying Microsoft’s ‘recommendations.’ This change has been well-received, as many users appreciate the cleaner look without those suggested apps cluttering their view.
<pInterestingly, one of the most upvoted comments in the aforementioned Reddit thread encapsulates the sentiments of many: "I'll tell you my thoughts when I finally get it." This highlights a surprising number of users still awaiting the rollout of the new Start menu, despite the official launch having commenced back in November 2025. As the rollout continues, some users are left hoping for further customization options, particularly regarding the app categorization feature, while others wish they had never received the update at all.
