The Rise of the Golden Idol review

Picture yourself on a bustling sidewalk, gazing at a row of apartment buildings. Instead of merely observing closed doors and drawn curtains, you possess an extraordinary ability to peer inside each dwelling, revealing the lives unfolding within. In one apartment, a couple sits at a dinner table, their body language hinting at an awkward first date. In another, a wall is plastered with notes, diagrams, and red string—an occupant deep in the throes of an investigation. But then, your attention is drawn to a more sinister scene: a man lies lifeless on the floor, a gun clutched in his hand, while in the laundry room, someone prepares to scrub away red stains from their shirt. The air is thick with suspicion.

Welcome to the gripping world of The Rise of the Golden Idol, where your role is to unravel not only the events that transpired but also the motivations behind them. Much like its predecessor, The Case of the Golden Idol, this sequel invites players to meticulously examine crime scenes, identify key figures, and weave together a narrative that explains the chaos. Each case is a clever puzzle, and the satisfaction of piecing together the clues is immensely rewarding, drawing you closer to a central mystery that threads through the entire game.

Gold standard

Two centuries ago, a mysterious artifact emerged, igniting a wave of violence as individuals vied for its possession. This premise set the stage for the critically acclaimed The Case of the Golden Idol, a standout in the detective game genre. In its sequel, The Rise of the Golden Idol, developer Color Gray Games transports players to the gritty 1970s, where the long-lost Idol resurfaces, and once again, bodies begin to pile up.

As in the original, players encounter frozen scenes that capture moments in time, each with subtle animations that suggest a brief loop of activity—a scientist staggering through a burning laboratory, or two individuals engaged in a heated argument. By clicking on various points of interest, players uncover details: a matchbook tucked in a pocket, a duty roster on a clipboard, or a gun lying carelessly nearby. Each discovery adds a few words to your investigation sheet, allowing you to construct narratives like a twisted game of Mad Libs.

To solve each scene, players must accurately identify the individuals involved and use their collected words to craft a coherent story. The process of gathering clues requires keen observation, as even the most innocuous details can hold the key to understanding a case. In one particularly perplexing mystery, I struggled to identify the catalyst for a violent encounter until I noticed a minute detail on a character that had eluded me in previous examinations. When the connection finally clicked, the entire scene fell into place, revealing the intricate web of events that had unfolded.

(Image credit: Playstack)

The narrative of The Rise of the Golden Idol is sprawling and, at times, bewildering. Unlike its predecessor, where the crime was often immediately identifiable, this sequel presents a more complex web of events. Players may find themselves investigating seemingly unrelated incidents, such as an attack at an animal sanctuary or a dispute at a talent show. However, as you delve deeper into these peculiar occurrences—like a fire at a drive-in theater or a medical emergency on a commercial set—the threads connecting them to the Idol gradually become clearer.

C.S. Idol

The art style of the original game was a delightful mix of crude pixel art that managed to convey charm despite its grotesque characters. In The Rise of the Golden Idol, the visuals have evolved to a smoother, more painterly aesthetic while retaining the quirky essence that fans loved. Color Gray Games has also introduced innovative features to enhance the detective experience. One standout scene allows players to interact with a TV show recording, enabling them to rewind, pause, and scrutinize each frame for clues. Another scene cleverly juxtaposes two different states of a room, revealing critical information only by toggling between the two timelines.

(Image credit: Playstack)

While The Rise of the Golden Idol may not completely replicate the brilliance of its predecessor, it remains a captivating and fulfilling detective experience. Some character motivations feel underexplored, and the final revelations may not evoke the same sense of triumph as before. Additionally, the increasingly lengthy recap puzzles at the end of each chapter can disrupt the flow of excitement. Nonetheless, these minor drawbacks do not detract from the overall enjoyment of the game. For fans of the original, this sequel offers another thrilling adventure, and for newcomers, there are now two intriguing detective stories waiting to be unraveled.

AppWizard
The Rise of the Golden Idol review