This week marked the unveiling of our much-anticipated annual Top 100 games list, a feat that required the collaborative efforts of over 30 writers and editors. The process was nothing short of exhaustive, involving spirited debates, impassioned discussions, and even presentations aimed at persuading colleagues. The fatigue is palpable, though it may also stem from the countless hours spent immersed in sprawling RPGs.
RPGs Dominate the Rankings
This year, an impressive 31 RPGs secured a spot on the list, with six of them making it into the coveted top 10. The standout titles include Baldur’s Gate 3, Disco Elysium, The Witcher 3, Crusader Kings 3, Caves of Qud, and Elden Ring. The influence of the RPG genre is undeniable, permeating even games that do not fit neatly into this category, such as XCOM 2 and Dishonored 2. This genre’s reach is expansive, and its impact is something to celebrate.
What sets the Top 100 apart is the remarkable diversity within the RPG genre itself. It encompasses a variety of sub-genres, including:
- Classic CRPGs
- ARPGs
- JRPGs
- Roguelikes
- Soul-likes
- Immersive sims
- Deck builders
- And even a game where you play as a flawed cop with a chatty necktie
This diversity is a testament to the genre’s ability to cater to a wide range of player preferences. Whether one seeks intricate narratives, opportunities for optimization, or simply a break from combat, RPGs provide a rich tapestry of experiences.
The Allure of Agency
At the core of many RPGs lies a familiar set of systems that invite experimentation. Players can explore various character builds, deck strategies, or even different personalities, fulfilling a fundamental desire for agency. Even the more linear titles allow for exploration, whether through vast open worlds or by creating unconventional character builds that surprise even the developers.
RPGs resonate deeply with gamers, offering a level of engagement that sets them apart from passive forms of entertainment like movies or books. They encapsulate the essence of what makes gaming an extraordinary hobby.
However, an interesting observation arises from this year’s list: despite the abundance of RPGs, none of the entries belong to the MMORPG category. While there are a few live service games featured, the absence of titles like Guild Wars 2, Final Fantasy 14, and World of Warcraft is notable. This shift indicates a growing preference for games that do not demand constant attention, steering players away from subscriptions and microtransactions.
In essence, while our love for RPGs remains steadfast, there is a clear desire for experiences that respect our time. The inclusion of Diablo 2 but not Diablo 4 exemplifies this trend, highlighting a collective aversion to time-wasting mechanics. This evolving landscape reflects a broader sentiment among gamers, as we seek meaningful engagement without the burden of ongoing commitments.
