This would have been an enormously consequential breach — if it was real. Shortly after claiming to have breached Max, the same user clarified that they had never achieved a large-scale breach or uncovered any critical vulnerabilities.
Fake cyberattacks can be as damaging as the genuine article
Perhaps unsurprisingly, there is a history of false claims regarding major data breaches. For example, a Russian hacking group named Mogilevich claimed in 2024 to have penetrated servers belonging to Epic Games, exfiltrating 200 GB of data. The attackers quickly turned around and admitted that their breach was a ruse designed to raise their profile, but the damage had been done. Many users believed the attackers’ claim on its face and either missed or ignored their retraction, causing significant reputational damage to their intended target.
Similarly in 2024, the car rental giant EuroCar reported that convincing reports of a widespread data breach were likely generated by ChatGPT. The attackers’ assertion convinced many customers, though, because they even went to the trouble of creating fake records and email addresses. Even if no data breach actually occurs, attackers can still benefit by creating false claims of a data breach at someone else’s expense.
False hacking claims may affect Max Messenger adoption
As it stands, Russian internet users already somewhat distrust Max. The application is widely perceived to be buggy and insecure, with more utility as a tool of state repression than as a genuine “super-app.” Even the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) initially blocked Max’s integration with other government services, citing the need for more robust encryption.
And although the government is intensely pressuring Russian citizens to adopt the Max app, there’s a difference between having the Max app on your device and using it every day. Here’s a likely failure of any mandatory government app: Citizens install the application as a show of compliance but continue to use other applications that are more convenient and less intrusive.
Meanwhile, there are many stakeholders who would be very interested in seeing this failure come to pass. The owners of Telegram and WhatsApp, for example — plus both NATO and the Ukrainian government — would all be happy to see the Max experiment fail.
Can we say definitively that the misinformation spread by CameliaBtw was a deliberate attempt by an interested party to derail adoption of Max in Russia? Absolutely not. Can we say that Russian citizens are already skeptical of Max and that they are primed to believe any damaging rumors about its security, regardless of their veracity? Absolutely yes.
Lastly, will we be surprised if there are more data breach claims about Max Messenger in the future?
Is your application vulnerable to information security misinformation?
If you’re reading this, you’re probably not developing an intrusive super app on behalf of a repressive government (we hope). But you may also be wondering, “If an attacker falsely claims to have breached my critical systems, how do I prevent this falsehood from damaging my reputation and my business?”
Here are three suggestions:
- Make sure that you already have a good reputation
If you haven’t already been breached, try to bolster your security such that you’re a difficult target for attackers. Experiencing a data breach in the past means that consumers won’t have difficulty believing false claims in the future. - If you experience a data breach, be open
Make sure that your data breach response protocols are well-honed. If you do experience a data breach, this means that you can respond quickly and transparently, preserving customer trust. Even if someone spreads a rumor later on, customers will be more open to your refutation of it. - Invest in digital forensics
If someone falsely claims that you’ve been breached, you want to be able to respond with a quick and decisive “no.” Many attackers get away so cleanly that their breach announcement is the first indicator of compromise. With the right tools, you’ll be able to be confident when you say that nobody ever breached your most critical data.
If you have any questions or concerns about protecting your organization from information security threats or misinformation, don’t hesitate to contact the experts at Barracuda. With Barracuda’s AI-powered cybersecurity platform and solutions that are easy to buy, deploy, and use, Barracuda can protect your data from a variety of complex threats and help you get out in front of misinformation. Schedule a demo and discover how Barracuda can help you strengthen your security posture and stay ahead of evolving cyberthreats.
